Take the standard advice and you will spend winter taking a daily vitamin D supplement. Sunlight grows scarce, the body cannot make enough on its own, and the supplement fills the gap – a common answer to winter vitamin D deficiency for anyone spending the season indoors.
It turns out the math changes when you exercise outdoors. A new trial tracked four groups of adults through the darkest months – and one group’s blood work landed somewhere nobody expected.
Winter vitamin D deficiency
The body manufactures most of its vitamin D when ultraviolet rays strike bare skin. About 80% of the body’s supply comes from that pathway.
In winter at higher latitudes, the specific band of ultraviolet light that triggers vitamin D production barely reaches the ground. Production slows to a trickle.
By current estimates, around one billion people worldwide carry a shortfall at any given time. Levels dip lowest in the months when daylight is briefest.
Vitamin D helps regulate calcium in the bones, supports muscle recovery, and keeps the immune system balanced.
Low readings have been linked to respiratory infections and slower healing – partly why the supplement industry around it has grown so large.
Setting up the trial
Researchers at the University of the Basque Country (EHU) in Spain joined colleagues at the University of Urbino (UniUrb) in central Italy for the trial.
Dr. Eneko Fernandez-Pena – a sport scientist at the EHU – helped design and run the study.
The team recruited 45 adults aged 20 to 45. About half were amateur runners who trained outdoors several times a week, and the rest had not done structured endurance work in the previous six months.
Half of each group took a daily vitamin D3 supplement delivered as a small dissolving strip, while the others took nothing. The protocol ran for eight weeks beginning in October, and everyone was followed into March with no supplements.
Blood tests tell the story
By December, the blood tests revealed a clear pattern. Vitamin D rose in everyone who took the supplement.
Runners on pills climbed about 21% above their October starting point. Non-runners on pills jumped nearly 29 percent.
Non-runners who took nothing went the other way. Their readings fell by roughly a third over the same eight weeks – a textbook case of winter vitamin D deficiency.
The runners who took nothing landed somewhere unexpected. Their levels held steady from October to December with no supplementation – likely because regular outdoor training kept them in contact with whatever sunlight December still offered.
Running rivals the pill
The most striking comparison came when researchers lined up the runners on nothing against the non-runners on pills. By December, the two groups had nearly identical vitamin D readings – same numbers, different paths.
Outdoor exercise had effectively done the work of a daily capsule. Sunlight on the forearms, calves, and back of the neck during runs was enough to hold blood levels steady, even as temperatures dropped and the days shrank toward the solstice.
The outdoor approach offers advantages that a capsule cannot replicate.
“Performing physical activity outdoors is a very effective strategy for combating vitamin D deficiency, and it also offers other health benefits that supplementation does not offer,” said Fernandez-Pena.
Immune system signals
Supplemented participants also showed steadier white blood cell counts. Neutrophils – the cells that respond fastest to infection – held closer to October baselines in the supplemented groups.
Non-runners who took nothing saw the steepest changes. Their total white cell count slipped almost 18%, and their neutrophil count fell by nearly a third – the biggest drop of any group.
Fernandez-Pena was careful not to oversell the finding. Supplements did not make anyone immune to colds or flu, but they did – in line with a body of related research – keep the body’s defenses on a more even footing through the dark months.
No edge in performance
Physical performance showed no meaningful change. Supplemented and unsupplemented participants posted nearly identical numbers across every metric the team tracked over three rounds of testing.
Maximum oxygen uptake barely budged in any of the four groups from October through March. An explosive jump test moved just as little.
A static leg-press strength test came closer to shifting in supplemented participants but fell short of statistical significance. The team flagged it as worth a closer look in future work.
Performance-enhancing drugs such as EPO – a hormone that boosts red blood cell production – work by altering the body’s physiology at a fundamental level. Vitamin D operates through an entirely different mechanism.
“Vitamin D is not like taking steroids or EPO. It doesn’t improve performance,” said Fernandez-Pena.
Earlier trials reported the same result – supplements raised blood markers without improving times, jumps, or strength scores.
A simpler prescription
Once the pills stopped, the seasonality of the whole system showed. By March, vitamin D had fallen in every group, including the runners who held steady all autumn.
Supplemented participants gave up most of their gains within 12 weeks of stopping. The runners on nothing also slipped as deep winter cut into outdoor training.
Non-supplemented non-runners finished with the lowest vitamin D levels recorded at any point in the study.
Until this trial, the two paths to preventing winter vitamin D deficiency had not been compared so cleanly in healthy adults.
Earlier work suggested outdoor exposure helped, but no one had shown that a runner’s routine could match a daily supplement directly.
Fernandez-Pena’s bottom line was short: skip the bottle if possible, and step outside. Spending 20 to 30 minutes at an easy pace several days a week, with a little skin exposed, can hold the line through winter and add something a pill cannot match.
The study is published in the journal Scientific Reports.
—–
Like what you read? Subscribe to our newsletter for engaging articles, exclusive content, and the latest updates.
Check us out on EarthSnap, a free app brought to you by Eric Ralls and Earth.com.
—–
Dining and Cooking