tl;dr for Ball's new formulation of their RealFruit pectin, you will likely need to double the actual amount of pectin to your recipe in order to get the jam to set as it had before.

I am a fruit farmer and make jam semi-commercially for farmers markets via a Cottage Food license. Ball pectin was my gold standard. I literally never had a jam not set when I dialed in a recipe, and I was willing to pay more money for that reliability.

Recently, Ball changed their pectin recipe. If you look at the new ingredients, everything is the same, except they have added sucrose (left, circled in red). The pectin itself is now much more sugary and white. Basically, they cut their jars with sugar, probably because it takes up volume and costs less than actual pectin, saving them money in production. I'm sure they will say it is to help with clumping or some nonsense.

Anyways, the new formulation was terrible. I went from a 100% set rate to literally a 0% set rate. Checking this subreddit I saw that many others also had the same issue. Not only did this screw over my markets for a week, it also likely invalidates every recipe in the Ball Blue Book that uses pectin, screwing over anyone who relies on Ball's own recipes.

Reading through other's struggles, most decided to move on to other brands and try out other options. I had just ordered a large amount of Ball's pectin from a warehouse, so I was stuck. I figured, if they cut the jars with sugar reducing the total proportion of actual pectin in each RealFruit pectin jar, maybe I just needed to add more of the pectin. For my next few batches I tried this out. I eventually discovered that when I literally doubled the amount of pectin, the jam would finally set, after about 24 hours.

This is a solution but it is still very frustrating. My input costs for pectin just doubled because Ball enshittified their product. I am very disappointed and will search for other options once my supply runs out. But, I figured I would post this, since most other posts struggles didn't post a solution that I could find, so maybe this post can help someone else out. Double the pectin, curse Ball corporate, move on.

by petran1420

10 Comments

  1. AutoModerator

    Hi u/petran1420,
    For accessibility, please reply to this comment with a transcription of the screenshot or alt text describing the image you’ve posted. We thank you for ensuring that the visually impaired can fully participate in our discussions!

    *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Canning) if you have any questions or concerns.*

  2. RememberKoomValley

    Oh, how tacky of them.

    Ball representative who I know will be reading this thread eventually, I’ll not be using your product anymore.

  3. This is insane! So many recipes call for a specific amount, and this is going to be a very big deal breaker for ball. What a fucking disappointment

  4. neongreenhippy

    Hi! Check out Nuts.com for bulk pectin. It’s extremely affordable and has an amazing set rate for me. 10.49/lb and can be bought by case for a discount or put on auto delivery for a different discount.

  5. BuyDaveaBeer

    As someone who is just starting thinking about making jam in 2 years, thank you for pointing out you need to read the label😉🍻

  6. Billsrealaccount

    Thanks for the heads up.  Won’t be using them anymore.

  7. DeaddyRuxpin

    I notice they also changed the pectin listing from “Fruit Pectin” to simply “Pectin”. I wonder if they are now also using pectin derived from beets or even some version of an artificial pectin. Perhaps the added sugar is to keep the flavor correct. The old was 1 gram of carbs and the new is still 1 gram of carbs but now caused by 1 gram of added sugar. It would seem like their pectin source has changed. I’d guess that is responsible for the lack of setting.

  8. creativeusagi

    I know you said you still have a lot of the ball pectin still, but as another suggestion I use the hoosier hill farm pectin and I have never had an issue with setting.

  9. whoframedwhiterabbit

    Can you not do a return to get your money back? 100% failure rate seems like the perfect reason to make them deal with their screw up. Then you can spend that cash on a product that works (when it eventually gets back to you). Otherwise they will continue on as usual.