Last summer my Fiancée and I got an ice cream maker. After making a few batches for ourselves, we had the idea to throw a party where we create a wacky (mostly) ice cream tasting menu with drink pairings like you would get at a fancy restaurant tasting menu.

It was a big hit and this year we ran it back with a slightly bigger guest list and plan to make it a yearly end of summer tradition moving forward.

We didn’t get a photo of it but the “???? Vs ????” Dish on the 2026 menu was a beanboozled style course/game where we walked around with 2 quarts of ice cream that looked almost identical and had people choose which one they wanted without telling them the flavors. One was Chicken Wing (Franks red hot + Blue cheese) and the other was blood orange creamsicle.

by PocketFoodAficionado

7 Comments

  1. What a genius idea! I want to do this now, thanks for sharing.

  2. bahuwrihi

    haha oh my f* goodness. How much work did go into making this? Describe a bit the process, how many People attended, what was the feedback, what are you plans/goals? Thank you, this is very cool and inspiring 🙂

  3. Torian17

    Amazing and what a lucky group of friends that got invited to your event!

  4. alpha_squared

    This is amazing! We’re hosting our first ice cream party in two days and yours is an inspiration to do this again!

  5. Aromatic-Bowler-2516

    *cries in lack of freezer space*

  6. icecreamnstickers

    Oh my gosh, this is amazing! I love your creativity and it’s such a wonderful idea to have an ice cream party. I would love to do something similar someday.