Ruthie Darling/NYT Wirecutter
Tasters found the Miss Jones Jumbo Bakery Style Double Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough to be scant in chocolate. The cookie was greasy and flat. And Miss Jones Almond Flour Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough had a rancid, musty oil flavor.
Tasters said that Sweet Loren’s Less Sugar Chocolate Chunk Cookie Dough was dense, grainy, and had an overwhelming powdery flavor.
Bakr Brown Butter Chocolate Chunk cookies had a wonderful, real-butter malty aroma, but upon tasting, they were aggressively one-note sweet.
The chocolate chips — bittersweet and balanced — were the best part of Ghirardelli’s Premium Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough. But the cookie itself was sandy, crumbly, uncannily beige, and it had an aerated, foamy quality.
While the Nestlé Toll House Chocolate Chip Lovers cookie looked appetizing, with generous chocolate chunks and a caramel color, it had a prominent chemical smell that many tasters said seemed artificial. The Nestlé Toll House Chocolate Chip Cookie tasted saccharine and similarly had a chemical, artificial flavor. And tasters found the Nestlé Toll House Remix Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie greasy, gray, and too sweet.
The pools of melted chocolate were visually promising in the Whole Foods 365 Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough. But the cookie was too molasses-forward, with a honeyed, fruity, liquor-esque harshness.
David’s Cookies Chocolate Chunk Cookie Dough baked up pale, and it had a distinct boxed yellow cake taste and texture that many tasters found unexpected and ultimately unappealing. David’s Cookies Gluten Free Chocolate Chip Dough had tasty chocolate, but the cookie had a doughy, sandy texture that made the cost and shipping wait tough to justify.
Tasters said that Trader Joe’s Super Chocolatey Gluten Free Chocolate Chunk Cookie Dough was gritty, sandy, and mushy.
Cappello’s Chocolate Chip Cookies with Flaky Sea Salt were greasy and had a strong coconut oil smell that overpowered every other flavor.
Eat Pastry Vegan Gluten Free Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough was gritty and grainy, and it tasted to one tester like “sandy apple sauce.” Eat Pastry Vegan Cookie Dough was flat, with oily bottoms and an equally oily flavor.
Tasters found Walmart’s Great Value Ready to Bake Regular Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough greasy, and it had an acrid, acidic aftertaste.
Pillsbury Chocolate Chip Refrigerated Cookie Dough was too sweet, disconcertingly pale, and skimpy on the chocolate chips, with a raw flour and chemical taste.
Doughy Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough baked up into nearly inedible dense pucks that tasted more of cashew than chocolate chip cookies.
Puff Chocolate Chip Cookies were gummy, one-note, and sugary, and they had a baffling puck-like shape after baking.
This article was edited by Marilyn Ong and Gabriella Gershenson.


Dining and Cooking