Clues From Beethoven’s Hair

The theory that lead poisoning contributed to Beethoven’s ailments gained traction in 2000, when scientists analyzed a lock of hair believed to have been clipped from the composer’s head shortly after his death. Known as the Hiller Lock, after the young musician Ferdinand Hiller, who reportedly collected it as a keepsake, the hair contained lead concentrations as much as 100 times the normal level.

But more than two decades later, the evidence took an unexpected turn. In a 2023 study, an international team of researchers examined eight locks of hair attributed to Beethoven in an effort to sequence his genome. To their surprise, the famous Hiller Lock belonged not to Beethoven, but to a woman, casting doubt on the earlier lead-poisoning findings.

The researchers did, however, authenticate five other locks. While their genetic analysis offered no answers about Beethoven’s deafness, it revealed that he had a genetic predisposition to liver disease and had been infected with hepatitis B, potentially helping explain the cirrhosis that contributed to his death at age 56. 

Then came another breakthrough. In May 2024, a team led by Nader Rifai, a professor of pathology at Harvard Medical School, published the results of toxicological tests on two authenticated locks of Beethoven’s hair, known as the Bermann and Halm-Thayer locks after their former owners.

The findings were striking: Lead concentrations were approximately 64 times the upper limit of the normal range in one sample and 95 times that limit in the other. The researchers also detected elevated levels of arsenic and mercury.

The researchers noted that such high lead levels are commonly associated with hearing loss, as well as gastrointestinal and kidney ailments. They suggested several possible sources of Beethoven’s exposure, including lead-adulterated wine, diet and medical treatments, but stopped short of concluding that lead poisoning caused his deafness.

Kuniyoshi Sakai, a neuroscientist at the University of Tokyo with a longstanding interest in Beethoven, is more convinced of the lead-poisoning hypothesis. “Other causes have been proposed for his deafness, including otosclerosis, syphilis, Paget’s disease and neural deafness,” he says. “However, none of them could fully explain his symptoms or autopsy results.”

Beethoven’s autopsy, performed the day after his death in 1827, revealed shrunken auditory nerves, with the left considerably thinner than the right. Sakai believes these findings suggest that his hearing loss was probably neurological in origin. He also argues that lead poisoning offers a single explanation for both Beethoven’s hearing loss and longstanding gastrointestinal problems.

As for where the lead came from, Sakai considers adulterated wine a particularly likely source. “His medical record did not suggest lead exposure as a treatment, and diet with lead consumption is unusual even in the 18-19th centuries,” he says, adding that “his progressive hearing loss is consistent with chronic lead poisoning, because his drinking habits were maintained throughout his life.”

Beethoven was certainly fond of wine. His physicians reportedly struggled to persuade him to abstain from drinking when he was ill, and his friend Karl Holz described him as a heavy drinker: “He drank a great deal of wine at table, but could stand a great deal, and in merry company he sometimes became tipsy.”  

But was the wine Beethoven drank actually contaminated with lead?

Dining and Cooking